Discussion and news about the modern effort to understand the nature of life on Earth, finding planets around other stars, and the search for life elsewhere in the universe

Monday, May 2, 2011

55 Cancri e: Small or Big?

Detecting and characterizing exoplanets remains an extremely challenging occupation. A very good example of this has been the recent detection of the transit of a planet around a star in the nearby stellar system 55 Cancri. This is an interesting place. It contains a binary star consisting of a G-dwarf and an M-dwarf separated by at least 1000 astronomical units. At only 41 light years away the G-dwarf is visible to the naked human eye and, conveniently, harbors at least 5 planets.

These worlds had been detected using radial velocity measurements, with the first detections back in 1997. A recent reanalysis of the notoriously tricky radial velocity data (made even more so with possible mean-motion orbital resonances in the system) by Dawson & Fabrycky suggested that the innermost planet "e" was actually on a much tighter orbit than had previously been thought - with the incredibly short orbital period of 0.74 days. This also suggested it was rather lighter than thought, a super-Earth of at least 8 Earth masses.

This was intriguing because the probability of a transit increases with decreasing orbital radius. In this case it went up by a factor of three to about 33%. This has prompted a number of groups to go look for the transit again, after earlier attempts came up empty. Lo and behold the first reported transit of 55 Cancri e appeared from Winn et al. on April 27th 2011. Using the visible light telescope of the Canadian MOST mission they spotted a transit right on queue. Hopefully Dawson and Fabrycky had some champagne at the ready.

Analyzing the depth of the transit curve (a tiddly drop in starlight of about 0.02%) Winn and colleagues came up with a planetary radius of approximately 1.6 times the size of the Earth. Combined with a mass of almost 9 times that of the Earth this implies a remarkable density of about 11 grams per cubic centimeter. That's almost as dense as lead, and a clear indicator that this is an almost pure rock-iron composition.

At least that would be the case, except on May 2nd 2011 another paper appeared by Demory and colleagues that uses the Spitzer infrared telescope to detect the very same transiting planet. With this different telescope and different waveband, a transit depth is found that indicates 55 Cancri e is about 2.1 times the radius of the Earth. The statistics are good enough that this is a "3-sigma" difference from the MOST detection, indicating that this difference in measured radius would only occur by random error about 0.3% of the time.

So, with a radius of 2.1 times that of the Earth this devious planet would have to contain a significant amount of volatiles and be much less dense. Possible compositions would involve a rocky-iron Earth-like core surrounded by either 20% by mass of water or 0.1% by mass hydrogen and helium. The problem is that 55 Cancri e is so close to its parent G-dwarf star that it should have an effective temperature of about 2000 Kelvin - all over. Hardly an environment for anything that could be called a "volatile".

Its quite a conundrum. Demory et al. perform their analyses very carefully. The most likely explanation - and one that Demory and colleagues offer up - is that 55 Cancri e harbors an extended atmosphere. Perhaps carbon monoxide or carbon dioxide as a super heated "exosphere" could produce an anomalous infrared surface that makes the planet look fatter than it is. That would likely indicate some interesting compositional properties if the planet is indeed as dense as the optical data suggest. Winn et al. investigate the constraints on an atmosphere from their data. It's very interesting. The odds seem slim. The only option appears that if such an atmosphere exists it is being constantly replenished by perhaps geophysical activity on the planet itself. The current status is therefore open to question.

There is hope however. Because the star 55 Cancri shines so brightly in our skies it provides a marvelous flood of photons and the potential for extremely high quality astronomical observations. Unlike many of the mysterious new worlds we merely catch glimpses of, this one may well reveal its secrets to us in due course. Exoplanetary science continues to grow in richness.

As I write this 55 Cancri is up in the western sky of the Eastern seaboard of the United States, amongst the constellation of Cancer, the Crab. Perhaps you should run out in case you can spot it - you never know, you might just catch a transit.

20 comments:

andy said...

Well intense geophysical activity might be quite plausible given the extremely small orbit and resultant strong tidal forces on the planet. Add in a nearby Jupiter-class planet in a 14-day orbit to provide gravitational perturbations and you might have a recipe for a world that would put Jupiter's moon Io to shame...

Unknown said...

Right, good points. I think there are a number of important questions about this planet. Although we'd expect/assume it to be tidally locked there are other psuedo-synchronous possibilities, and as you point out the Jupiter class object a little further out will perturb the orbit - although by how much I've not calculated. I'd also be curious to see what tidal bulge this planet raises on the star at this close orbit - it could be enough to basically ensure a tidally driven orbital decay (espec. because the star appears to be a slow rotator).

Cleaning Company Dubai UAE said...

Kid care choices are a lot more - childcare professional, manny (the male childcare professional), babysitter, au set, baby health professional, governess, day time care, kid care discussing, mother's assistant, and friends and family. But, usually, the option is in between hiring the babysitter or perhaps a nanny. baby sitting dubai

Nadkaar - web design said...

Thanks ! for sharing this wonderful news with us.I really like your post as it is informative as well as interesting.
"web design dubai"

Unknown said...

Incredible post. Thank you for sharing great information.
SEO Dubai

Alston clayden said...

You share amazing information which makes me read your blog frequently. Keep up the good work.
Media Relations company in Dubai

Rhino Dubai said...

Twice as large as Earth, the super-Earth 55 Cancri e was thought to have magma streams on its surface. The planet is so near its star, cleaning services in dubai a similar side of the planet consistently faces the star.

Blog27999 said...

Did you realize there is a 12 word phrase you can communicate to your partner... that will induce deep feelings of love and impulsive appeal to you buried inside his heart?

Because hidden in these 12 words is a "secret signal" that triggers a man's instinct to love, cherish and protect you with all his heart...

12 Words Who Fuel A Man's Love Instinct

This instinct is so built-in to a man's mind that it will drive him to try harder than before to do his best at looking after your relationship.

In fact, fueling this mighty instinct is absolutely mandatory to having the best ever relationship with your man that as soon as you send your man one of the "Secret Signals"...

...You will soon find him expose his mind and heart for you in a way he haven't expressed before and he'll identify you as the one and only woman in the world who has ever truly interested him.

Barbara John said...

Buy amd R7 in US at none other than Tetris Shop, choice of more than thousand users in USA

Barbara John said...

Contact ECO Services for identifying the type and intensity of pest problem and experience effective pest eradication from work space, production facility or home

Amin Akhtar said...

Exploring the natural beauty with Village Organics Pakistan , talent and pure organic products of Gilgit Baltistan.complete information about, apricot, apricot oil, seabuckthorn, salajeet,herbs and providing online organic store for all above village products.

TheBEGlobal said...

Thanks for Sharing. We offering the SEO Services in Dubai at reasonable price and make it rank higher in search results.

BEGlobal(US)LLC said...

Thanks for Sharing. BE Global LLC is a leading Social Media Marketing Company in Michigan that helps you boost your brand awareness, increase sales, and More.

Sudhan said...

Thanks for providing this good blog and related information. We provides best SEO services in Dubai help businesses improve your website visibility, ranking, traffic, conversion rates, and overall online presence.

BEdigitech said...

Thanks for sharing. Bedigitech is established SEO Company in India. Bedigitech will assist in increasing a company's qualified leads, conversions, and sales by assisting websites in being found by their intended audience.

Anonymous said...

I would like your content its really nice and unique content. Print On Wood Share store details, promotions, or brand content with your customers.

CareTaker said...

We provide effective and guaranteed pest control services to residential, commercial and industrial clients in Pakistan. We are trusted for providing best pest control solutions because we provide warranty for our pest control services.

Home Advisor said...

Home Advisor Water Tank Cleaning Services In Karachi are designed to provide you with clean and safe water for your family. With our professional cleaning services, you can ensure that your water tanks are free from contaminants and bacteria.

THEPOOLAPK01 said...

Snooker pool is a classic and highly strategic cue sport that demands precision and skill. It's a game of finesse, concentration, and strategy, making it a beloved choice for players who enjoy a mental challenge along with their cue ball action

Attestation Services said...

MOFA Attestation Dubai streamlined the document legalization process for us. Their efficient services saved us time and ensured our documents were ready for use in the UAE without any hassle. Highly recommended!